Arbeitspapier
A flow measure of missing women by age and disease
The existing literature on "missing women" has suggested that the problem is mostly concentrated in India and China, and mostly related to sex-selective abortions and post-birth neglect of female children. In a recent paper in the Review of Economic Studies, Anderson and Ray (AR) develop a new "flow" measure of missing women in developing countries by comparing actual age-sex-specific mortality rates with "expected" ones. Contrary to the existing literature on missing women, they, and the World Bank which subsequently followed this method, find that gender bias in mortality is much larger than previously found (4-5 million excess female deaths per year), is as severe among adults as it is among children in India, is larger in Sub-Saharan Africa than in China and India, and existed on a large scale in the US around 1900. We first show that the data for Sub-Saharan Africa used by AR are generated by simulations in ways that deliver the findings on Africa (and the US in 1900) essentially by construction. We also show that the findings are entirely dependent on a highly implausible reference standard for sex-specific mortality from rich countries that is inappropriately applied to settings in developing countries; the attempt to control for differences in the disease environment does not correct for this problem and leads to implausible results. When a more appropriate reference standard is used, most of the new findings of AR regarding the regional and age composition of missing women disappear.
- Sprache
-
Englisch
- Erschienen in
-
Series: Discussion Papers ; No. 254
Economics of Gender; Non-labor Discrimination
Equity, Justice, Inequality, and Other Normative Criteria and Measurement
Health: General
gender bias
mortality
disease
age
Sub-Saharan Africa
China
India
Vollmer, Sebastian
- Handle
- Letzte Aktualisierung
-
12.07.2024, 13:22 MESZ
Objekttyp
- Arbeitspapier
Beteiligte
- Klasen, Stephan
- Vollmer, Sebastian
- Georg-August-Universität Göttingen, Courant Research Centre - Poverty, Equity and Growth (CRC-PEG)
Entstanden
- 2018
Ähnliche Objekte (12)
Counting missing women - A reconciliation of the "flow measure" and the "stock measure"
Missing Women: Age and Disease: A Correction
Counting missing women: A reconciliation of the "flow measure" and the "stock measure"
Counting Missing Women - A Reconciliation of the 'Flow Measure' and the 'Stock Measure'
Counting Missing Women – A Reconciliation of the 'Flow Measure' and the 'Stock Measure'
Counting missing women: A reconciliation of the "flow measure" and the "stock measure"
Excess female mortality in Africa
Missing women: some recent controversies on levels and trends in gender bias in mortality
How the new international goal for child mortality is unfair to sub-Saharan Africa (again)
A Turning Point in Gender Bias in Mortality? An Update on the Number of 'Missing Women'
Female employment and Spousal abuse: A parallel cross-country analysis of developing countries
What explains uneven female labor force participation levels and trends in developing countries?
Counting missing women - A reconciliation of the "flow measure" and the "stock measure"
Missing Women: Age and Disease: A Correction
Counting missing women: A reconciliation of the "flow measure" and the "stock measure"
Counting Missing Women - A Reconciliation of the 'Flow Measure' and the 'Stock Measure'
Counting Missing Women – A Reconciliation of the 'Flow Measure' and the 'Stock Measure'
Counting missing women: A reconciliation of the "flow measure" and the "stock measure"
Excess female mortality in Africa
Missing women: some recent controversies on levels and trends in gender bias in mortality
How the new international goal for child mortality is unfair to sub-Saharan Africa (again)
A Turning Point in Gender Bias in Mortality? An Update on the Number of 'Missing Women'
Female employment and Spousal abuse: A parallel cross-country analysis of developing countries
What explains uneven female labor force participation levels and trends in developing countries?
Counting missing women - A reconciliation of the "flow measure" and the "stock measure"
Missing Women: Age and Disease: A Correction
Counting missing women: A reconciliation of the "flow measure" and the "stock measure"
Counting Missing Women - A Reconciliation of the 'Flow Measure' and the 'Stock Measure'
Counting Missing Women – A Reconciliation of the 'Flow Measure' and the 'Stock Measure'
Counting missing women: A reconciliation of the "flow measure" and the "stock measure"
Excess female mortality in Africa
Missing women: some recent controversies on levels and trends in gender bias in mortality
How the new international goal for child mortality is unfair to sub-Saharan Africa (again)
A Turning Point in Gender Bias in Mortality? An Update on the Number of 'Missing Women'
Female employment and Spousal abuse: A parallel cross-country analysis of developing countries